#ActivityPub vs #ATProtocol
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJBCpzM1VfM

Más que #Mastodon, #Bluesky y #Threads, lo que «me pone» es el uso de protocolos como #ActivityPub y #ATProtocol. Moverte entre instancias llevándote todo y sin mirar atrás.

Creo que no me ponía tanto algo como desde el boom de la geolocalización con Gowalla, Foursquare, etc.

@fancysandwiches

#JackDorsey's manifesto is alleged in some circles to be the defining outline for the #ATProtocol #ATProto

I have yet to read anything from anyone who has performed an audit of the #Bluesky source code, as installed and in use, to verify that it implements the #ATP as it's claimed to do

@lrhodes @John @jdp23 @inquiline

@fringemagnet

It's important to read and ponder:

"a native internet protocol for social media" ~ Jack Dorsey
DECEMBER 14, 2022

particularly the summary:

"1) Social media must be resilient to corporate and government control.

2) Only the original author may remove content they produce.

3) Moderation is best implemented by algorithmic choice"

Dorsey spells out what the #Bluesky implementation of the #ATProtocol is --> supposed <-- to be about

https://americanbuddhist.net/2022/12/14/a-native-internet-protocol-for-social-media-jack-dorsey/

cc @duke_of_germany

@jezebelley

Operative phrase: "supposed to be"

The #Bluesky source code is on Github

I've not heard anyone who confirms that the claims for the AT Protocol are actually *found* in the source code

And "decentralized" is the claim

Until there's multiple instances online and publicly available, that's PR smoke-and-mirrors

Links:

"bluesky-social" @ Github

https://github.com/bluesky-social

The #ATProtocol aka Authenticated Transfer Protocol, aka #ATProto

https://atproto.com/guides/overview

cc @richardgrant

@micahflee

"I think one big difference with atproto decentralization vs. Mastodon is that atproto is one huge flat network graph"

Host names and IP addresses for the top ten #Bluesky instances currently online and active, please

Oh

There aren't any

There is *no* #ATProtocol decentralization

It's a #JackDorsey marketing / PR play

Period

Compare and contrast:

https://fedidb.org/network

cc @vegetarianzombie @DemocracySpot @Mastodon

@mastodonmigration

From what I've read of it, "controlling your algorithms" is you getting to choose radio buttons from a list of canned topics or you get a couple fields to enter keywords into, give it a name, save it, and it's "yours"

It's a #Bluesky / #ATProtocol PR play

It is *not* going to make anyone into a coder bro, or give anyone the control of a coder bro, no matter how much the Bluesky fanbois suggest it will

cc @koteisaev @ClimateMigration

@Imoptimal

The only difference is that #Jack and #Bluesky and the #ATProtocol seem to be farming out algo content and legal liabilities to unknown/unnamed third parties

While #Musk and #Twitter are still trapped with it in-house

The real sticking point in implementing portable accounts/ nomadic identity in the ActivityPub branch of the #fediverse - like what Zot and AT Protocol offer - is its implications for how moderation works.

"The hard part however, is the social one: we collectively need to agree that the identity resolution layer is infrastructure and not somewhere moderation actions should take place."

https://shadowfacts.net/2023/activitypub-portable-identity/

#ActivityPub #Zot #ATProtocol

@codesmith

This is fast becoming boilerplate:

Embrace.

Extend.

Extinguish.

Do those words mean anything to people?

Why does anyone think anything about #Metabook / #Instadon and #Zuckerberg are going to suddenly become good Samaritans in the world?

#Meta #Pixelfed #Mastodon #Activitypub #ATProtocol

@stefan

"But again, what are the alternatives? I'd personally rather have them embrace ActivityPub than AT/Nostr."

One alternative would be for people to stop fluffing #Metabook / #Instadon and #Zuckerberg at every opportunity

Which has been pretty epidemic lately

Zuckerberg can have the #ATProtocol

Let Zuck and Dorsey fight it out over who's doing what to whom and for what reason

One of the lead #Bluesky #Dev’s is doing a livestream and explaining the protocol while working.

https://www.youtube.com/live/D6FBGfrXazw?feature=share

#ActivityPub #ATprotocol

why does #bluesky and #ATProtocol exist ? ActivityPub already exists and is widely used ...

@lapingvino

Yes. VHS came later, Betamax already had a huge foothold and VHS won.

We are on the same page.

Now do #ActivityPub and #ATProtocol and remember, Jack Dorsey has access to the deepest pockets on the planet to bring his vision of federated social media to life.

#Bluesky's #ATProtocol compared to #ActivityPub and #Twitter. https://educatedguesswork.org/posts/atproto-firstlook/

منصة #بلوسكاي_سوشال اللامركزية التي أعلن #جاك_دورسي عن إمكانية التسجيل المسبق لاختبارها. يطرح السؤال :هل هي البديل المحتمل لمنصة #تويتر؟ مع تحيات #نايلةالصليبي
#blueskysocial
#Twitter
#ATProtocol

https://mc-d.co/1mE6

Jack Dorsey unveils decentralized social with algo choice and portable accounts

https://cointelegraph.com/news/jack-dorsey-unveils-decentralized-social-with-algo-choice-and-portable-accounts

#AuthenticatedTransferProtocol #decentralizedsocialmedia #portableaccounts #ATProtocol #algorithm #Bluesky #ADX

Reading....

#ATProtocol #Twitter #Bluesky

https://atproto.com/docs