New Yorker: No More Souters https://www.newyorker.com/podcast/the-new-yorker-radio-hour/no-more-souters #NewYorker #Podcast/TheNewYorkerRadioHour #SupremeCourtJustices #U.S.Constitution #DavidSouter #Originalism #Roev.Wade
#newyorker #podcast #supremecourtjustices #U #davidsouter #originalism #roev
He summarized the article’s conclusion: “Donald Trump cannot be president — cannot run for president, cannot become president, cannot hold office — unless two-thirds of #Congress decides to grant him amnesty for his conduct on #Jan6.”
#DisqualifyTrump #14thAmendment #conservative #law #Trump #ineligible #president #Constitution #insurrection #FederalistSociety #legal #originalism
#congress #jan6 #disqualifytrump #14thamendment #conservative #law #trump #ineligible #president #constitution #insurrection #federalistsociety #legal #originalism
Two prominent #conservative #law professors have concluded that #Trump is #ineligible to be #president under a provision of the #Constitution that bars people who have engaged in an #insurrection from holding government office. The professors are active members of the #FederalistSociety, the conservative #legal group, & proponents of #originalism, the method of interpretation that seeks to determine the Constitution’s original meaning.
#conservative #law #trump #ineligible #president #constitution #insurrection #federalistsociety #legal #originalism #disqualifytrump #jan6 #14thamendment
#Conservative Case Emerges to #DisqualifyTrump for Role on #Jan6
Two law professors active in the #FederalistSociety wrote that the original meaning of the #14thAmendment makes #Trump #ineligible to hold #government office.
#law #president #Constitution #originalism #insurrection #legal
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/10/us/trump-jan-6-insurrection-conservatives.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
#conservative #disqualifytrump #jan6 #federalistsociety #14thamendment #trump #ineligible #government #law #president #constitution #originalism #insurrection #legal
Two lawyers with conservative Federalist Society are publishing a paper in The University of Pennsylvania Law Review next year. They argue that under #originalism, the 14th amendment makes it clear that “Donald Trump cannot be president — cannot run for president, cannot become president, cannot hold office — unless two-thirds of Congress decides to grant him amnesty for his conduct on Jan. 6.”
"If he were 'convicted and sentenced,' Trump was asked on the John Fredericks Show, 'does that stop your campaign for president?'
'Not at all,' Trump replied. 'There’s nothing in the Constitution to say that it could'.”
~David Badash
Originalism, baby! America's first Mafia-boss president was clearly envisaged by the Constitution, and don't try to convince me otherwise! (sarcasm here).
#Trump #crime #criminal #Republicans #LawandOrder #Constitution #originalism
#trump #crime #criminal #republicans #lawandorder #constitution #originalism
That's it
Game over
#LeonardLeo and the #FederalistSociety and their hand-picked #SCOTUS Justices have rendered the #UnitedStatesofAmerica into an #EvangelicalChristian / #CatholicDominionist #Theocracy
All that #Constitutional #Textualism and #Originalism was a lie
The #UnitedStates is now a #Theocratic dictatorship
And #JoeBiden and the #DemocraticNationalCommittee have already told us their response:
Send out fund-raising emails and tell us to vote
For them
Again
#leonardleo #federalistsociety #scotus #unitedstatesofamerica #evangelicalchristian #catholicdominionist #theocracy #constitutional #textualism #originalism #unitedstates #theocratic #joebiden #democraticnationalcommittee
That's it
Game over
#LeonardLeo and the #FederalistSociety and their hand-picked #SCOTUS Justices have rendered the #UnitedStatesofAmerica into an #EvangelicalChristian / #CatholicDominionist #Theocracy
All that #Constitutional #Textualism and #Originalism was a lie
The #UnitedStates is now a #Theocratic dictatorship
And #JoeBiden and the #DemocraticNationalCommittee have already told us their response:
Send out fund-raising emails and tell us to vote
For them
Again
#leonardleo #federalistsociety #scotus #unitedstatesofamerica #evangelicalchristian #catholicdominionist #theocracy #constitutional #textualism #originalism #unitedstates #theocratic #joebiden #democraticnationalcommittee
That's it
Game over
#LeonardLeo and the #FederalistSociety and their hand-picked #SCOTUS Justices have rendered the #UnitedStatesofAmerica into an #EvangelicalChristian / #CatholicDominionist #Theocracy
All that #Constitutional #Textualism and #Originalism was a lie
The #UnitedStates is now a #Theocratic dictatorship
And #JoeBiden and the #DemocraticNationalCommittee have already told us their response:
Send out fund-raising emails and tell us to vote
For them
Again
#leonardleo #federalistsociety #scotus #unitedstatesofamerica #evangelicalchristian #catholicdominionist #theocracy #constitutional #textualism #originalism #unitedstates #theocratic #joebiden #democraticnationalcommittee
@maxkennerly Oh well. There goes the #FDA. Looks like every FDA drug approval can be relitigated in the 5th circuit now. #Originalism at its very best.
One of my law articles actually appeared in a Wis S. Ct decision (well dissent, as usual): "See, e.g., Caroline Mala Corbin, Opportunistic Originalism and the Establishment Clause, 54 Wake Forest L. Rev. 617, 618 (2018) (describing the United States Supreme Court's use of originalism as "opportunistic because sometimes the Court relies on it, and sometimes it does not.")."
Decision was Wisconsin v. Hoyle
Article: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3388102
#law #lawfedi #lawprof #fedilaw #originalism #yay
Remember the constant #GOP #SupremeCourt #SCOTUS braying about #Textualism and #Originalism and #OriginalIntent?
All lies
The GOP cares about the US #Constitution about as much as it cares about the #Bible
Find one passage they need right now
Misinterpret it to their immediate ends
Ignore all the rest
Or make something up out of whole cloth
Either way, throw it away when it's no longer needed
#gop #supremecourt #scotus #Textualism #originalism #originalintent #constitution #bible
"In the hands of Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito and other conservatives on the Supreme Court, the founding fathers are small-minded and provincial, unable to think beyond the narrowest possible interpretation of the words they wrote.” #JamelleBouie #FoundingFathers #Originalism #SupremeCourt https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/25/opinion/bouie-newsletter-framers.html
#supremecourt #originalism #foundingfathers #jamellebouie
@heidilifeldman @Dahlialith Thank you. #Originalism has always been an absurdity.
@RuthZ @heidilifeldman @Dahlialith
"...Clarence Thomas can read the Framers' minds"?
You mean all that #Textualism and #Originalism crap?
All lies
Thomas and the #GOP care about the US #Constitution about as much as they care about the #Bible
Find one passage they need right now
Misinterpret it
Ignore all the rest
Throw the first one away when it's no longer needed
#Textualism #originalism #gop #constitution #bible
A few things that U.S. historians know that are worth emphasizing for the general public:
1. Many of the earliest and most prominent originalists were slave owners who made originalist arguments to protect slavery.
2. They invoked the Bible and antiquity in their apologias.
3. That you can find northern originalists and anti-slavery Christians does not imo diminish 1 & 2.
#Slavery #Christianity #Originalism #Constitution #Histodons #History
#slavery #christianity #originalism #constitution #histodons #history
#originalism #gopdeathcult #gopdomesticterrorists
Even a #Conservative jurist and essayist I know from the #Antebellumera recognized that original meanings behind the Constitution had to evolve according to popular will, a position more enlightened and sophisticated than the 6 GOP hacks on today's #SCOTUS .
#PoliticalHistory #LegalHistory #Originalism #FakeOriginalism #GOP #GOPextremism
#conservative #antebellumera #scotus #politicalhistory #legalhistory #originalism #fakeoriginalism #gop #gopextremism
#Breaking: #Originalism is a crock, invented by regressive #judges to put an academic-sounding label on their outcome-oriented decision-making process.
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2023/02/gun-laws-bruen-clarence-thomas-framers-domestic-abuse.html by @Dahlialith @heidilifeldman
#breaking #originalism #judges #law #scotus #constitution #judicialactivism
"Originalism fails its own test": David Cole on the fallacies of "originalism" in legal interpretation in the United States. #111Words #SCOTUS #NewYorkReviewOfBooks #DavidCole #Originalism https://andrewjshields.blogspot.com/2023/02/originalism-fails-its-own-test-david.html
#originalism #davidcole #NewYorkReviewOfBooks #scotus #111words