Claudia Solis-Lemus · @solislemuslab
413 followers · 395 posts · Server mstdn.social

Life's paradox: waiting for months to get reviews of a paper, and receiving them on the week that you cannot possibly do one more thing 😅

#publishorperish #publication #reviewprocess

Last updated 2 years ago

Claudia Solis-Lemus · @solislemuslab
439 followers · 452 posts · Server mstdn.social

Life's paradox: waiting for months to get reviews of a paper, and receiving them on the week that you cannot possibly do one more thing 😅

#publishorperish #publication #reviewprocess

Last updated 2 years ago

Today, I took the extra step to write to the editor to tell him that I disagreed with . The argument was IMO flawed, and I found it unfair that the person could just suggest the authors re-do the analysis with some statistical methods to make it "more novel." I'm not sure if I overstepped my role in the process, but I felt I had to say something.

ecoevo.social/@floryannelli/10

#Reviewer2 #reviewprocess

Last updated 3 years ago