Bruce Hamilton · @bahome
185 followers · 133 posts · Server mastodon.social
KaminskiMed :verified: · @Kaminskimed
457 followers · 1949 posts · Server med-mastodon.com
RT @KaminskiMed@twitter.com
Thought about @harvardmed@twitter.com & @usnews@twitter.com. Searched deeply inside. No. I do not have any opinion about this. Also no feeling. Simply nothing.
But, I’m a great fan of @hmkyale@twitter.com - so I guess it’s important 👇🏼
Question: what about #USNWR hospital ranking should this be dropped? https://twitter.com/hmkyale/status/1615378286267310082
Andrew Millar · @A_J_Millar
183 followers · 180 posts · Server fediscience.orgInstitutions should publish the data that they provide to #UniversityRankings organisations.
Students/applicants/some funders use rankings despite oversimplification etc. Withdrawing, as US law schools and others from #USNWR, is likely a good response but leaves a vacuum.
Research-grade data might support a better system, #OpenScience style.
HT @petersuber @hughshanahan @nikivermeulen @malcolm_macleod
#OpenScience #usnwr #UniversityRankings
petersuber · @petersuber
3181 followers · 385 posts · Server fediscience.orgUpdate. I won't keep extending this thread indefinitely. But I do want to add that #HarvardMedicalSchool just joined #HarvardLawSchool in refusing to take part in the #USNWR #rankings.
The story in the Harvard Crimson
https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/1/18/harvard-medical-school-us-news/
The story in the Washington Post
https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/01/17/harvard-medical-school-us-news-rankings-admissions/
#rankings #usnwr #harvardlawschool #HarvardMedicalSchool
KaminskiMed :verified: · @Kaminskimed
457 followers · 1940 posts · Server med-mastodon.comThought about @harvardmed@twitter.com & @usnews@twitter.com. Searched deeply inside. No. I do not have any opinion about this. Also no feeling. Simply nothing.
But, I’m a great fan of @hmkyale@twitter.com - so I guess it’s important 👇🏼
Question: what about #USNWR hospital ranking should this be dropped?
L.S. Views & Rankings Report · @lsvrr
3 followers · 14 posts · Server ohai.social
petersuber · @petersuber
2668 followers · 218 posts · Server fediscience.org
Update. Now add the U of #Virginia and #NYU law schools.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2022/12/09/uva-law-school-us-news/
That makes 14 major US law schools that have stopped participating in the USNWR rankings: #Yale, #Harvard, #Berkeley, #Columbia, #Georgetown, #Stanford, #Michigan, #Northwestern, #Duke, #UCIrvine, #Penn, #UWashington, #Virginia, and #NYU.
#rankings #usnwr #lawschools #uwashington #Penn #UCIrvine #duke #northwestern #michigan #Stanford #georgetown #Columbia #berkeley #Harvard #yale #nyu #virginia
petersuber · @petersuber
2612 followers · 205 posts · Server fediscience.org
Update. Now add the U of #Washington and the U of #Pennsylvania law schools.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2022/12/03/law-schools-protest-us-news-rankings/
That makes 12 major US law schools that have stopped participating in the USNWR rankings: #Yale, #Harvard, #Berkeley, #Columbia, #Georgetown, #Stanford, #Michigan, #Northwestern, #Duke, #UCIrvine, #Penn, and #UWashington.
#rankings #usnwr #lawschools #uwashington #Penn #UCIrvine #duke #northwestern #michigan #Stanford #georgetown #Columbia #berkeley #Harvard #yale #Pennsylvania #washington
petersuber · @petersuber
2339 followers · 152 posts · Server fediscience.orgUpdate. Now add the #UCIrvine School of Law.
https://www.law.uci.edu/news/in-the-news/2022/11-23-ucilaw-usnews-ranking.html
That makes 10 major US law schools that have stopped participating in the USNWR rankings: #Yale, #Harvard, #Berkeley, #Columbia, #Georgetown, #Stanford, #Michigan, #Northwestern, #Duke, and #UCIrvine.
#rankings #usnwr #lawschools #duke #northwestern #michigan #Stanford #georgetown #Columbia #berkeley #Harvard #yale #UCIrvine
CyberDean07 ✅ · @cyberdean07
81 followers · 221 posts · Server esq.socialThe Top 11 Law Schools that Withdrew from the U.S. News & World Report Law School Rankings (in their order of withdrawal):
1. Yale; 2. Harvard; 3. UC Berkeley; 4.Columbia; 5. Georgetown; 6. Stanford; 7. Michigan; 8. Duke; 9. Northwestern; 10.UCLA; 11. UC Irvine
petersuber · @petersuber
2268 followers · 137 posts · Server fediscience.org
Update. Now add #Northwestern Pritzker School of Law.
https://news.law.northwestern.edu/us-news-rankings-participation/
That makes 8 major US law schools to date: #Yale, #Harvard, #Berkeley, #Columbia, #Georgetown, #Stanford, #Michigan, and #Northwestern. #Penn is still deliberating.
#rankings #usnwr #Penn #michigan #Stanford #georgetown #Columbia #berkeley #Harvard #yale #northwestern
A. Krenelka Chase · @akrenelkachase
73 followers · 3 posts · Server mastodon.lawprofs.orgDid all of these #lawschools pull out of #USNWR #rankings because I made such a compelling argument? 🤣
TSajalK · @TSajalK
1 followers · 5 posts · Server mastodon.world
Fascinating time to watch #T14s decide they no longer want to participate in #USNWR #lawschool #rankings https://abovethelaw.com/2022/11/yale-law-school-pulls-out-of-u-s-news-rankings-like-michael-jordan-skipping-slam-dunk-contest/
#t14s #usnwr #lawschool #rankings
Pamela Foohey · @bankruptcyprof
212 followers · 55 posts · Server mastodon.lawprofs.org
salopecon · @ssalop
100 followers · 79 posts · Server econtwitter.netGeorgetown Law just withdrew from #USNWR ranking system. Dean said decision was independent. So no #antitrust issues. Not #collusion
John Belmont · @jwbelmon
171 followers · 109 posts · Server humangenetics.socialPlan to do a full review of US News and World Report #USNWR #Pediatric Hospital rankings.
The key is the scoring system. Preview - it has the fingerprints of bias and self interest all over it. How can it not include ENT and Ophthalmology??
Maybell Romero · @Maybellromero
1576 followers · 368 posts · Server mastodon.socialCongrats on pulling out of #USNWR #rankings, @berkeleylaw! #lawprofs #lawfedi #lawschool
#usnwr #rankings #lawprofs #lawfedi #lawschool
